6.9 KiB
6.9 KiB
Hero comparison: SLP Software (SLS) vs Andrea Slop Fotografie (ASF)
Input for the requirements of hero-module. Sources: SLS = src/features/landing/components/Hero.tsx, src/features/landing/data/content.ts (heroContent), src/prerender/StaticLanding.tsx, src/variants/e/Era2026.tsx (read from the code by the CMS session, 2026-11-16); ASF = web/src/components/Hero/*, web/src/content/heroContent.ts, types.ts (delivered by the ASF session, 2026-11-16). Nothing here is a design decision yet; the decisions of Bryan are at the end.
Comparison
| Aspect | SLS (Tailwind) | ASF (Chakra) | Same / different | Consequence for the CMS content |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small label above the title | eyebrow ("Web & .NET development"), shown in the code strip below |
tagline ("Lifestyle fotograaf · Huizen"), a small uppercase label above the title, in the same h1 |
Same idea (short label), different place | One short text field ("tagline"); the site decides where it goes |
| Title | heading ("SLP software: websites, apps & meer", screen-reader only) and displayHeading (3 lines: "Websites," / "apps" / "& meer."); the era variant joins the lines with a space |
title ("Andrea Slop"), one string, in the h1 with the tagline |
Different: SLS has a visual line split | One title text; line breaks as a separate optional representation (decision needed) |
| Lead / subtitle | lead (long paragraph, about 250 characters) |
none | SLS only | Optional "subtitle/lead" text field |
| Code line | codeLine ("var website = slp.Bouw(uwIdee);") with blinking caret |
none | SLS only, a style element | Not CMS content unless Bryan wants it editable (decision needed) |
| Buttons | Two: "Bekijk pakketten" (anchor #pakketten), "Plan een gesprek" (anchor #contact). Labels hardcoded in Hero.tsx; the era variant takes them from nl.json (era.e2026.ctaPackages/ctaContact) |
One: cta {label "Lees meer", to "/over-mij"}, an internal route |
Same idea (label + target), different count and target kind (page anchor vs site route) | 0..2 buttons, each label + target; the target is free text that the site interprets (anchor, route or address) |
| Images | None | slides[], 8 images of 220 to 440 KB, JPG, one file per slide, no srcset or variants, object-fit cover, 100svh |
Different | 0..n slides: the SLS hero has zero |
| Per slide | n/a | id (stable), src, alt (also read by the screen reader as "Photo n of N: alt"). No per-slide label, link or caption |
ASF only | Slide: image, alt text, order; stable id |
| Display | Static, no slider | Slider: 6 s per slide, crossfade, slow zoom, pause on mouse hover / keyboard focus / hidden tab / pause button (WCAG 2.2.2), arrows and swipe, wrap-around; one slide = no arrows and no autoplay | Different | Optional "display" value (single / slideshow) that every site renders as it supports; the site keeps the timing and animation |
| Reduced motion | Not relevant (no motion beyond the caret) | prefers-reduced-motion: no autoplay, no progress bar, no pause button, no zoom |
ASF only | Stays in the site |
| Noscript | The prerendered landing contains the hero text | Slide 1 stays as a static <img>; progress bar hidden; arrows and pause need JS |
Both readable without JS | The first HTML must contain the hero (LCP) without JS |
| LCP | The text (heading) | The first slide image | Different | Host injection per kind: text for SLS; for ASF the first slide <img> with fetchpriority="high", width/height, srcset and a matching <link rel="preload" as="image"> |
| Loading | Everything in one page, text only | Active slide first; next and previous after onLoad plus 2 frames; the rest while advancing |
ASF only | The host writes only slide 1 into the HTML; the site loads the rest from the data block |
| Prerender | StaticLanding renders the Hero into #root at build time (no hydration; createRoot replaces it) |
Prerendered with the first slide and a preload link; slides 2 to 8 are empty wrappers | Same pattern (baked HTML, replaced by the app) | Host injection fills the baked hero and puts the full hero in the data block |
| Variants | Five era variants (Era1989 to Era2026) in variants/e/; only Era2026 shows the hero content, it joins displayHeading |
One layout | SLS only | Same content for every variant; the site renders it. The CMS has no layout choice |
| Where the text is now | content.ts (heroContent), button labels in Hero.tsx and nl.json (era) |
heroContent.ts; aria texts ("Uitgelicht werk", "n van N", "Foto n van N") in the components |
Both in code | Title, tagline, lead, buttons and alt texts move to the CMS; the aria texts go to the site's own language file, not the CMS |
| Socials | none in the hero | HeroSocials bottom left, from siteContent.socials |
ASF only | Outside the hero module (site-wide) |
| CMS data today | Packages and banner via markers in index.html; the hero is not part of it |
Packages and banners via markers and #cms-data ({siteUrl, offerings, banners}); the hero is not part of it |
Same host contract | The data block gets a hero key; the baked hero stays the fallback (fail-open) |
| Image address | n/a | Vite import with hashed name in /assets/ |
n/a | CMS media URLs: the preload URL must equal the img src exactly; CSP img-src must allow the media host (same origin avoids a change) |
What is the same (core of the CMS content)
Title (text), a short tagline, optional lead text, 0..2 buttons (label + target), and a list of 0..n slides (image, alt text, order). The sites differ in presentation, count and kind of buttons, and in whether slides exist.
Decisions of Bryan (relayed by SLP Software - SLS - Main, 2026-11-16)
- Same approach as packages and forms: the CMS delivers content only; every site keeps its own layout and presentation (ASF Chakra, SLS Tailwind). No layouts or sketch choice in the CMS or in the react package. A sketch choice may come later, with a third site.
- The hero content comes entirely from the CMS: texts (title, tagline/subtitle), buttons (label, link) and images (0..n slides with image, alt text and optionally text per slide). Optionally a "display" field (for example single / slideshow) that every site renders according to its own support.
- The comparison (this file) comes first; the question file is adjusted to what remains. Bryan answers both in one go.
- The hero LCP (image or text) must be in the first HTML (prerender / host injection), and content is live (NFR-10).
Facts from the sites that the design must respect
- ASF: the order of the slides decides the LCP; the first CMS slide must be in the first HTML with a preload whose URL is exactly the
imgsrc. - ASF proposes the data shape
hero {title, tagline, cta{label,url}, slides[{id, imageUrl, width, height, alt, srcset?}]}and delivers golden files after Bryan approves the requirements. - ASF aria texts and the 6-second timing stay in the site; they move to the site's language file.
- SLS has no images; its hero has a lead and two buttons.